Bach at One in St. Paul’s Chapel
by Trent Gilliss, senior editor
The Trinity Choir and Baroque Orchestra rehearse in St. Paul’s chapel.
We’re in New York tonight preparing for tonight’s live event with Hendrik Hertzberg, Serene Jones, and Pankaj Mishra. The subject? Reflecting on 9/11 and who we want to become as a people and a society as we think forward about the next decade. The location?
St. Paul’s Chapel near Ground Zero, a centering place of refuge and aid for rescue workers and volunteers.
Performing a sound check, we got a great surprise: the Trinity Choir and the Trinity Baroque Orchestra rehearsing for their daily Bach at One concert. So, this week’s Tuesday evening melody is a bit rawer, an on-the-ground capture of one of the many other events taking place to commemorate the attacks of 9/11. Bach never sounded so right.
Tuesday Evening Melody: “Aria da Capo” from Glenn Gould 1981 Goldberg Variations
by Nancy Rosenbaum, producer
This week’s Tuesday evening melody is inspired by a listener question’s about last week’s show. On the heels of hearing “Autism and Humanity,” Chase Fairfax posted this comment on our blog:
“I wonder what the orchestra music was that punctuated this story from time to time.”
We think Chase is referring to Glenn Gould’s 1981 version of the “Aria da Capo” of Bach’s Goldberg Variations.
Some of Gould’s biographers have speculated that he may have had Asperger’s syndrome. Gould was sensitive to noise and temperature; he hated the sound of clapping and wore a hat, coat, and gloves, even in warm weather. He was also known for rocking and humming when he played. He stopped giving public concerts at the age of 32.
Gould preferred his 1981 rendition rather than his earlier recording from 1955. According to music critic Tim Page who interviewed Gould about the two versions, the 1981 recording “has a certain sadness and sense of reflectiveness… an autumnal quality.” As it turns out, Gould was in the autumn of his own life as these later recordings were being produced; he died of a stroke at the age of 50, just before the 1981 recording was released.
If you want to compare the two versions, check out the show’s playlist for the 1955 version. Which one do you prefer?
Photo courtesy of Library and Archives Canada.

